Unfortunately for Hook, Archie did know him and did remember. He tensed as the pirate spoke to him, Pongo starting to get to his feet. He quieted the Dalmatian before they caused a scene.

"Hoo--Killian," Archie greeted nervously, correcting himself. Killian. The man went by Killian now.

To be honest, it wasn't pure chance that kept them from seeing each other. The pirate made the cricket nervous as he was a reminder of that time aboard the Jolly Roger.